I’m going to offer up two stories using the same subject, each told in three pictures.

All the artwork is by Church Goin Mule and in Clarksdale, Mississippi, home of The Blues. I think that the ghost mule’s hind legs are partly obscuring ‘Blessissippi’.

If you’ve heard how ‘it nice!’ sounds in the appropriate accent, you’ll need no help here beyond the reminder in the font. If you’ve missed out, when reading the words, smile. Heavily emphasise ‘Nice!’, load it with as much enthusiasm as you can muster and finish it off with a twist of surprise.
Possums may need an explanation too. They’re marsupials, and quite steady characters, despite their ability to feign death. And they’re easy to please. Unlike a picky diner, it’s easy to imagine them thinking, ‘it nice!’ about a slug, an over-ripe persimmon or a bit of a day-old boiled egg.

‘Strength lies within’ is underlined when the exterior surface is crumbling. The wave-like flourishes are made from woven material so stand just proud of the wall, ready to start their own peeling off.
This first trio is the selection I would more naturally share. Their story is upbeat and quirky. The colours and textures are alive, if muted. The visual ‘sound’ has been turned down; some of the interference is filtered out.
In the alternative series of images, a slightly wider crop turns up the visual interference. An equally affirmative message (‘Blest’) has been substituted for the message above. The story and mood are changed.

When we see more of the context, we may start to wonder if the artwork is on inside walls, not outside ones. We notice the plaster is crumbling to the paint-splashed floor and wonder how long it will be before the artwork joins it. With more going on, the message edges towards being a colour-carrying squiggle. We may note the decided direction of travel is from man-made to nature. How big will those vines and pavement weeds get?

Does ‘Blest’ seem ironic in the context of a far from newly-derelict building complex a few hundred steps from a town centre? Artful neglect inspires a blend of respect and rapture in the music pilgrim, but may be less appealing if you are poor and you live or work among it.
Does it influence us that Clarksdale is built on the cultivated cool of neglect? Just as the patina of use raises the value of an age-worn antique, any attempt to clean or modernise risks lowering the value by making it more ordinary.

The artwork remains just as cheery, no matter the crop, wouldn’t you say? Happy within its context. The wall can and will crumble, but the artwork is there for now, and now is all there is.
Is one threesome of pictures more direct or honest than the other? Does hope need to turn a blind eye to inconvenient truths like loss, neglect or poverty if it is to soar?
I suspect the highest, most rare happiness is able to fully hold sadness within it.
In an article by Lucy Pearson published today, she asked Timo Auvinen to explain the secret behind Finland’s six years of world-leading happiness according to the Word Happiness Report. He replied, ‘Finns have several sayings about their quest for happiness. They include, “the pessimist will never be disappointed” and “happiness always ends in tears”, but also, “nothing is so bad that there’s nothing good in it”’. Their gist was that, as with the possum’s diet, lower expectations are easier met.
That’s as may be, but I’d rather see Mule’s folksy Southern Outsider Art affirmations painted on a wall than ‘happiness always ends in tears’, even if the building that provides a canvas is open to the skies and well on its way to earth.

I’m ending with an arty shot. It was taken through a strangely intact window of the same derelict building looking out towards the Delta Cinema which is stylishly advertising an event from 30 months ago. I loved the colours, the lost-world, palimpsest effect of the reflections, the out of kilter crookedness, and all those tangled wires which I’d normally look to crop out.
Visit Church Goin Mule’s website for more of her creations. She describes herself as ‘Song-miner and story-shiner’. Her artworks often feature mules with legends such as ‘Don’t have to live big to live happy’. I found her quoted as saying, ‘I was thinking about my neighbor. How tall would he be if he was measured in stories? Most folks around here are twenty, thirty stories tall.’
Clarksdale is a great place for street art, much of it just ‘a little bit back from the main road’. To take your chance to reframe the artwork shown here, venture into the building/complex nearly opposite the Delta Cinema on 3rd Street, Clarksdale, MS.
Shared for the Lens-artists Challenge: Telling a Story.

What a fantastic idea to consider how the story changes as you pull out from a tight crop! I love to photograph details but i’m aware without a wider shot to provide context my photos could be misinterpreted, just as you demonstrate here. Is a building in good repair or crumbling? Is it really old or just pretending to be so? Are we inside or out? Your post poses all those questions and more – and then answers them 😀
And as an aside, I love the notion that a person could be measured in stories. Wouldn’t the most interesting of them tower above the rest of us?!
I tend to look at details too. I wonder if that’s connected to being able to see better close up than further away? This was one of many topics in my to-post queue, but I wasn’t sure which series I liked best. The topic gave me a good excuse to share and compare both.
Hi Susan. I’m going to echo Sarah’s comment…a fantastic idea to reframe the photos and compare the effect on the message. Your “blest” image with the ruins in the background is my favorite here, along with the strangely intact movie marquee. Great storytelling!
Another great topic. Thanks for hosting!
Wonderful post, Susan. I love how your mind works.
I’m glad you enjoyed it.
You always bring a unique interpretation to the challenges, Susan. Like Pat said. I love the way your mind work. I do see the walls as art. The strength lies within is a grand message and should be wall art or a greeting card. And I like the Blest photo. There is beauty in ambiguity. Well done.
Thanks for your kind comment.
You are welcome.